For the past fortnight, foreign residents in Brazil have found themselves unable to complete some of the most ordinary steps of their immigration journey. Since around 4 November, SISMIGRA, the system through which the Federal Police register foreign nationals and process their requests, has been unavailable or intermittent across much of the country. Forms fail to load, pending requests cannot be consulted, and appointments have quietly disappeared from the calendar.
What made the episode particularly unsettling was the silence that accompanied it. As late as 13 November, the Federal Police's national press office denied that there was any fault, even as regional offices were confirming the difficulties to those who enquired. Only on 17 November did the institution publicly acknowledge the outage.
Its statement is, on its face, reassuring. Appointments affected by the disruption are being rescheduled, and no migrant is to be penalised or regarded as irregular solely on account of the system's unavailability. There is, however, a condition attached: the applicant must be able to show that they attempted to complete the procedure within the legal deadline. The protection is therefore not automatic. It rests entirely on evidence.
In practical terms, anyone with a pending obligation towards the Federal Police would be well advised to keep a dated record of every attempt to access the system, ideally screenshots showing the date, the time and the error displayed, and to write to their local migration office explaining the situation. This matters more than it may appear. Following the publication of a residence authorisation in the Diário Oficial, the applicant has thirty days in which to request registration, and fines for late registration are not uncommon. Decisions published by the Federal Police show that such fines have been upheld even where the applicant argued that no appointments were available, simply because the claim could not be substantiated.
The outage, it should be said, is less an anomaly than an aggravation of a familiar state of affairs. Appointment availability has long varied considerably from one city to another, waiting times can stretch from weeks to months, and practice is not always uniform between offices applying the same regulations. The system was under strain well before it went offline.
A quieter shift at the Ministry of Justice
Alongside the difficulties at the Federal Police, a less visible change has been taking place higher up the chain, at the Ministry of Justice and Public Security, which decides residence applications before registration takes place.
Since approximately mid October, practitioners have observed a marked tightening in the way applications are assessed. Private documents, such as service agreements between a self employed applicant and a foreign client, are now expected to bear an apostille and to be drafted to Brazilian standards. Documents that were routinely accepted until recently, a jointly signed certificate of services for instance, are being rejected, and files already under examination have been reopened with requests for further evidence. None of this has been set out in a published resolution or ordinance.
It is difficult to consider this development in isolation from the broader concern over document fraud. Only this week, an investigation in the Federal District brought to light a scheme in which foreign nationals obtained Brazilian passports by presenting false consular certificates purporting to show that they were the children of Brazilians born abroad. The authorities have not linked the current tightening to such cases, and it would be imprudent to assert a direct causal relationship. Yet the climate is one in which those responsible for granting status are understandably inclined towards caution.
Why the rules change without being published
To those accustomed to other administrative traditions, the most puzzling aspect is that a requirement of this kind can be introduced without any formal text. In Brazil, it is a fairly characteristic feature of administrative practice, and several factors help to explain it.
The first is that, from the administration's standpoint, nothing new is being created. The applicable regulations already allow the Ministry to request supplementary documents and to carry out such checks as it considers necessary, and Brazil has applied the Hague Apostille Convention since 2016. Requiring an apostille on a private contract may therefore be presented as a stricter application of existing powers rather than as a new rule.
The second is a matter of procedure. Amending a resolution of the National Immigration Council requires deliberation by the Council and publication in the Diário Oficial, whereas an internal instruction to case officers may take effect almost immediately.
The third is that discretion has an obvious value in combating fraud. An authority seeking to detect forged documents has little interest in publishing a precise inventory of what it now examines and how.
Finally, an unpublished practice is considerably harder to challenge. A formal rule may be contested before the courts; a request for additional evidence made in an individual case rarely is.
The consequence is a widening gap between the rules as written and the rules as applied, one that is visible chiefly to those who handle applications on a regular basis. For applicants, the sensible course is to anticipate the more demanding standard: to apostille foreign documents as a matter of course, private ones included, to ensure that contracts and supporting letters are complete and properly executed, and to retain evidence of every exchange with the authorities. Brazil remains a deeply rewarding place in which to settle, but its administration rewards those who prepare for the practice rather than the text.